Welcome to Henry's Bagel Cafe
At Henry's Bagel Cafe, we celebrate the art of bagel-making in the heart of Hillsdale, NJ. Our story began with a passion for high-quality, freshly baked bagels, crafted with precision to achieve a perfect balance of lightness and texture. We pride ourselves on our welcoming atmosphere and exceptional customer service, making every visit a memorable experience. From delicious breakfast wraps to hearty sandwiches, our menu caters to all tastes, backed by rave reviews from our loyal patrons. Whether you grab a cup of coffee or indulge in our homemade chicken salad, Henry's Bagel Cafe is about community, comfort, and culinary excellence.
Henry's Bagel Cafe: Reviews & Ratings
The competition is stiff for bagel places in the tri-state area, and specifically in the Hillsdale area. But what sets Henry's apart is that the awesome food is provided by nice people. The bagels are great. The breakfast wraps are excellent. And everything is prepared fairly quickly. While you wait, you can chat up the people who work here, who come to recognize the regulars. It just makes the place feel more comfy. Its hard for me to recommend a specific wrap or sandwich because all of them have been good. They offer your typical sausage, egg, and cheese but also healthier fare like egg white and spinach wraps. Also you can get fresh orange juice or smoothie/juices from the menu. We love this place!
Bagel competition in zipcodes that start with a 0 or 1 is fierce. That's just a fact. If you're gonna make it in the bagel game, you've got to be on-point all the time. Henry's Bagel Cafe is brings it. Every day. This place is great. Bagels are arguably perfect. They're both light and airy yet also have with a solid crust with just enough bite. They don't go heavy on the seasoning -- they're just right. Cream cheese options are plentiful and they know how to make an egg. Like, really know how to make an egg. If Henry's popped up in your search for a bagel, you should come here... is this the best bagel in North Jersey? You tell me...
I remember when Ronnie opened Ronnie's. This is same WOW factor, best bagels and very reasonable price
Best bagel sandwich in the area, bagels are perfectly toasted and perfect amount of egg
Although I've only had a few items so far, everything has been delicious! Henry and his wife, Maria are very gracious and welcoming hosts. The chicken noodle soup rivals any I've had so far, also the chicken salad. Their prices are reasonable and we'll worth the value.
got an everything bagel w lox spread. the bagel went dummy, had a nice hollow feel to it. the lox spread was very fresh too. one of the better bages you could get in the area
Henry's is the best. Awesome family run business always fast and polite. Good prices and extensive menu. Great food
This is my new go-to bagel spot when I visit the area. Remember when Ronnie's used to be THE BEST like a decade ago and everyone was obsessed? This is how good Henry's is. Honestly best bagel I've had in years. Bacon egg n cheese you can't go wrong. Their lunches look good too - they use quality boar's head.
My daughter ordered, of all things from a bagel cafe, a burger and fries. She was amazed at how good it was. Not greasey, even the fries were great ( I did steal a few). My egg salad sandwich was nice and the staff was helpful and pleasant. Great lunch stop!
Location
-
321 Broadway #1, Hillsdale, NJ 07642 Hotline: (201) 383-0038
Welcome to Henry's Bagel Cafe, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Hillsdale, NJ. Located at 321 Broadway #1, this cozy eatery has carved out a niche for itself in the competitive bagel landscape of the tri-state area. With a commitment to quality ingredients and a welcoming atmosphere, Henry's has become a local favorite for bagel lovers and sandwich enthusiasts alike.
As you step into Henry's Bagel Cafe, you're greeted not just by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked bagels but also by the friendly faces of the staff who are eager to make your experience enjoyable. Patrons often rave about the strong sense of community here; many feel right at home as the staff remembers their names and orders.
The menu at Henry's is a delightful combination of classic and innovative offerings. You can indulge in perfectly toasted bagels, known for their light, airy texture and satisfying crust. Whether you prefer a traditional sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich or a healthier egg white and spinach wrap, there’s something for everyone. The bagels are complemented by an impressive selection of cream cheese options, ensuring that every bite is bursting with flavor.
- Highlights from the Menu:
- Delicious wraps like the Buffalo Chicken Wrap and the Grilled Vegetable Wrap, each priced at $9.99.
- Quinoa bowls such as the Greek Quinoa Bowl and Power Quinoa Bowl, perfect for a wholesome meal at $11.25 to $12.49.
- Customer favorites like the Chicken Salad Sandwich for just $8.49.
What truly sets Henry's apart is not just the food but the experience. Regulars like George B. and Emil R. consistently share their enthusiasm for the warm, welcoming vibe and quick service. The reviews speak volumes about the dedication to quality and customer satisfaction that the team at Henry's embodies. Beyond just bagels, the menu includes comforting options like chicken noodle soup and fresh juices, all prepared with care.
Henry's Bagel Cafe also embraces sustainability; they offer compostable containers and allow customers to bring their own containers, making it not just a place to eat, but a place that cares about the environment.
In conclusion, whether you’re stopping by for a breakfast bagel or a satisfying lunch wrap, Henry’s Bagel Cafe offers an unparalleled experience that will keep you coming back. With fair prices and a commitment to their craft, it's easy to understand why so many consider it a worthy contender in the battle for the best bagels in North Jersey. The question remains—will Henry's be your new go-to for bagels? We think it just might be.
